The Post Millennial: The Tories' Newest Mainstream Propaganda Outlet Collaborates With Violent Bigots

 

                    On August 22, 2019, Emma McIntosh of the National Observer published an expose on the editor of the Post Millennial at the time, Cosmin Dzsurdzsa.  Dzsurdzsa is the husband of the unsuccessful far-right campus activist and fellow True North Centre contributor Lindsay Shepherd. McIntosh correctly reported on Dzsurdzsa’s past work for the neo-Nazi Russia Insider.  After that stint, Dzsurdzsa worked with Alexander van Hamme as a correspondent for the white nationalist website Free Bird Media.  Later work published to Anti-Racist Canada would demonstrate that Dzsurdzsa himself was keenly interested in the neo-Nazi ideology of Aleksandr Dugin, which informs the editorial stance of Russia Insider.  Both Dugin and Russia Insider have a dependent financial relationship with the sanctioned oligarch Konstantin Malofeev. Moreover, that same work uncovered a second editorial hire’s participation in Russian disinformation operations.  Former TPM American Section Editor Alexandra Hollenbeck was also poached by the Post Millennial from Free Bird Media, being recruited around the same time as Dzsurdzsa. Dzsurdzsa has since left The Post Millennial for True North Centre, a far-right think tank dedicated to xenophobic and homophobic causes.  The fact that they have hired a man known for covert Nazi activism speaks to the nature of the extremist agenda that organisations like TPM and True North Centre seek to advance. Disturbingly, both The Post Millennial and True North Centre were explicitly named as media approved by Andrew Scheer in his final speech as Leader of the Opposition, and Scheer implored supporters of the Tories to inform themselves using those websites. 

    After publication of MacIntosh’s piece, the site produced an attack in response, seeking to discredit MacIntosh with personal attacks.  The article’s graphic used a photograph of MacIntosh, photoshopped to have a tin-foil hat on her head.  The site made no effort to refute MacIntosh’s findings, instead opting to suggest that the National Observer journalist is mentally ill.  Co-founder Ali Seyed Taghva took to claiming MacIntosh’s work was a “lazy, disingenuous, guilt-by-association smear.”  I have had my own interaction with the notoriously disingenuous Mr.Taghva after I inquired as to the reason why Ms. Hollenbeck’s articles were removed from the Post Millennial. Taghva tried explaining to me that the Post Millennial does not delete material, and that the content in question was “lost in a server move.”  I had not believed Mr. Taghva’s lies then, and I certainly do not now.  The Post Millennial was one of many far-right disinformation rags that falsely reported on an edited video of US President Joe Biden as being real.  The article was wiped from The Post Millennial website immediately after fact-checkers caught on to the broader lie.  In doing so, it appears the Post Millennial has avoided fact-checking reviews of its material, allowing it to benefit from disinformation without facing public consequences to its reputation. Gaslighting is institutionalised in the company, as evident in its endeavours, past and present.  McIntosh, myself, and other critics are branded as conspiracy theorists with the entire backing of the company and its astroturfed megaphone.  It has also persisted in acting as a platform for foreign disinformation, even going so far as to publish propaganda decrying anti-racist protests as “colour revolutions,” a pejorative utilised in Russian disinformation to delegitimise democratic protests in the former Soviet Union.  Its author is Sumantra Maitra, a man who previously worked as a propagandist for the People’s Republic of China.



Taghva will gaslight his critics, calling them racist conspiracy theorists instead of responding to the question.  Taghva’s claims that a server move just so happened to erase pro-Russian disinformation put out by Hollenbeck is wholly unconvincing.  The implication of Taghva’s statement would be that the Post Millennial failed to detect and remove that content itself.


 The Post Millennial does not simply harass and slander its critics, but goes out of its way to place targets on the backs of those it deems its political opponents.  Several of its staff members have been involved in far-right harassment campaigns, going so far as to produce disinformation about victims of extremist harassment as a means of protecting the reputations of involved extremists.  Post Millennial’s Andy Ngo has already become infamous for being present during a vicious assault perpetrated by members of the far-right extremist organisation Patriot Prayer. Ngo was alleged by an infiltrator of the extremist organisation to have a reciprocal arrangement with Patriot Prayer, providing them with favourable coverage in return for protection at demonstrations.  Ngo went out of his way to dox the woman those Patriot Prayer members assaulted, effectively intimidating a witness on behalf of the organisation Ngo was already accused of aiding.  The infiltrator turned over video evidence of the men plotting the attack, and Ngo aimlessly walking around them.  This pattern of behaviour is not exclusive to Ngo.  In fact, the operations of the Post Millennial website could be best described as a commercialisation of political violence, in which the sensationalist demonization of private citizens, and the incitement of violence towards them become the primary means of collecting revenue from advertising and donations. 

     In this sense, the Post Millennial has much in common with Der Sturmer and Radio Télévision Libre des Mille Collines.  While it is not making direct calls for murder, the Post Millennial uses a variety of rhetorical tactics to incite violence against others, such as falsely claiming that journalists are “antifa sympathisers,” or claiming that a subject of frequent abuse was responsible for the suicide of her former lover.  In a lecture for the University of Oregon, Katherine Hubler details the use of selective identification by Der Sturmer as a means of targeting Jewish Germans and political opponents, and its use in exposing audiences to examples of supposed “Jewish immorality and crime” (Hubler 28:57).  The Post Millennial takes on a similar behaviour, weaving a broad narrative in which left-wing political activists, racial and sexual minorities, and critical journalists collaborate in a vast conspiracy to undermine so-called “western civilisation.”  It seeks to impress upon its readership an apocalyptic vision of cities across the United States being burned down by communist mobs, predatory homosexual and transgender people brainwashing children to be gay by means of their very existence, and a cabal of journalists intent on abetting it all.  These narratives are designed to instill a violent sense of desperation and fear within its audience, who are led to believe that their political opponents are not simply the most reprehensible individuals on the planet, but an existential threat to themselves, their family, and their country.  Retributive violence against their opponents then becomes not just simply justifiable, but a moral imperative in defence against an existential threat.  This is why the “Great Replacement” conspiracy theory propagated by Generation Identity (including Canadian member Lauren Southern), the Christchurch mass shooter, Rebel Media, and Tucker Carlson are all extremely dangerous.  In the case of Carlson, he is frequently defended by the Post Millennial in its articles, and Post Millennial editors Andy Ngo, Libby Emmons, and Nico Johnson are all frequent guests on his show.  Carlson’s invocation of the Great Replacement is as a direct justification to disenfranchise immigrants and people of colour, claiming that immigration and the existence of black people is part of a conspiracy to “dilute” the voting weight of white Americans.  Carlson has since been subject of a boycott by Holocaust remembrance organisations.  For the purpose of analysis, the Post Millennial will be compared to the operations of far-right media that were also involved in inciting violence.



Radio Télévision Libre des Mille Collines (RTLM), Kangura and other propaganda of the Rwandan Genocide:


     RTLM was a radio station dedicated to spreading hate propaganda on behalf of the far-right Hutu nationalist movement and was a participatory entity in the genocide, acting to broadcast the names and personal information of victims as part of an incitement to murder.  Those victims would then experience their homes being attacked, and themselves and their families murdered, often by being hacked to death with machetes.  The Habyarimana regime’s permissiveness of Hutu violence created an environment in which outright calls for murder and genocide were normalised, as opposed to modern hate propaganda in democratic states.

     Sexual propaganda was one of the primary means of dehumanising Tutsis and Hutu moderates.  Victims of sexual assault during the genocide were depicted as sexually promiscuous and utilising their sexuality as a means of subverting the “values” or “purity” of Rwanda.  Female victims are reduced to being “whores” in the complexes of the genocidaire, and the victims’ supposed sexual crimes are used as justification for sexual violence.  Women and opponents of the Hutu supremacist far-right were depicted as sexual objects within pornographic propaganda, and individual women were singled out to be subjected to violence as so-called “race traitors.” The hate pornography of the Genocide was extremely popular among Hutu supremacists, and had both sexualised Tutsi women and framed them as malicious as a means of justifying violence against them.

Denialism was a strong component of Hutu supremacist propaganda following the Genocide. In Season of Blood, Fergal Keane recollected his conversations with two university rectors that were sympathisers of the Hutu supremacist movement.  Both men were keen on denying the very existence of a genocide in the days after local massacres.  The wholesale slaughter of Tutsi civilians was framed as simply casualties of war.  These denials are a form of disinformation crafted specifically for the purpose of whitewashing extremist movements on the world stage.  By portraying victims as perpetrators and selectively reporting on political violence to the benefit of extremist perpetrators, sympathetic media rewrite history and memory altogether, silencing victims and further inviting retribution on those same victims.





Der Sturmer:

Writing for Modern Judaism, Denis Showalter analysed letters to Der Sturmer, detailing the often obscene narratives of grievances submitted by its devoted fanbase (177).  Part of what made Der Sturmer effective as a propaganda model was its capability to outsource its material from its audience by publishing letters and other content submitted by readers.  As Showalter notes, Der Sturmer and other Nazi papers lacked skilled staff, instead relying on its audience to participate in a process of self-radicalisation through the generation and submission of antisemitic content (173).  This content was also useful in determining what narratives would be most useful to advance the messaging of the Nazis (174).  Frequently the content of Nazi papers were focused on sexual grievances and explicitly targeted individual women for supposed sexual impropriety (often so-called “miscegenation” with Jews).  One case involved a man alleging his wife ran away with a Jew to become a prostitute, telling the audience the city where he believes his wife lives (180), placing that woman at the mercy of a violent audience.  The focus on a narrative of Jews as sexual predators was another key aspect in this propaganda, which often included graphic details of improprieties, sexual violence, and harassment.  These were frequently used as means of incitement towards Jews and women.  According to Hubler, the Pillory column of Der Sturmer frequently listen the names, locations and photographs of women who allegedly had relationships with Jews (27:25), essentially pornography for a sexual fantasy premised on the audience’s sexual insecurities, which today is seen in the alt-right’s preoccupation with racialized cuckoldry and transgender women properly being in women’s spaces.   Der Sturmer would specifically seek out stories of Jews as sexual predators (14:05).  The purpose in doing so was to create the appearance to its audience that Jews are overwhelmingly responsible for sex crimes. 

    Der Sturmer frequently denied incidents of antisemitic violence.  In the wake of Kristallnacht, Der Sturmer denied any violence occurred (20:42).  This behaviour allowed Der Sturmer to whitewash the crimes of anti-Semites to lend an air of respectability to them.   Denialism served to temper public outrage over the violence of antisocial thugs and functioned as an expression of power common to authoritarian societies, in which factual bases are not accepted in any objective sense, and “truth” is instead determined by the mass line of the movement.

 

The Post Millennial In Comparison:

 

     To compare the means and tactics of The Post Millennial to these publications is not to say that the publication engages in direct calls for genocide, produce pornographic cartoons, or propagate an explicitly extremist programme.  The Post Millennial does not operate exactly like the aforementioned genocidal media because doing so is not commercially viable, and a liability to the patrons of the website.  Rather, the content of The Post Millennial is adapted for a legally and culturally different context than Nazi Germany or Hutu Supremacist Rwanda. It does not broadcast the names of victims to be hacked to death with machetes, it simply broadcasts the names of victims to incite nonspecific threats and violence. It hires writers with histories of collaborating with malicious stalkers.  Instead of specific ethnicities, it targets the LGBTQ+ community, black people, and perceived political opponents, typically women.   Its aims are varied and based on appeals to specific audiences, rather than a singular nationalist movement.  Instead of devotion to narratives of Jewish or Tutsi perpetrators and German or Hutu victims, The Post Millennial depicts Black perpetrators brutalising Asian victims as means of undermining discourse on white supremacist hate crimes, sex crimes with transgender perpetrators as means of undermining criticism of transphobic hate crimes, and minor property damage during antiracist protests to present a false equivalence to far-right political violence and terrorism.  

  The hate publication has taken cues from neo-Nazi and former GOP congressional candidate Paul Nehlen and started portraying transgender people and drag performers as sexual predators intent on brainwashing children with “Drag Queen Story Hour,” less than a year after Nehlen’s announced campaign to target those specific events.  Often this has included insinuations of government participation in a nefarious plot against children. Aside from its coverage being disproportionately devoted to stories involving transgender individuals and drag events, The Post Millennial has published content and interviews from a number of anti-LGBTQ+ groups affiliated with Konstantin Malofeev’s World Congress of Families, including the Campaign Life Coalition and CitizenGo.  Its promotion of the Campaign Life Coalition and the corresponding hyperlinked propaganda video were produced in collaboration with Culture of Life an organisation tied to Russian influence operations targeting the evangelical lobby, including the World Congress of Families and CitizenGo.

It has recently taken to publishing anti-trans extremist bloggers, which has already resulted in the website being used to aid a B.C. man in harassing his transgender son and his medical practitioners. This focus on legitimising harassment of 2SLGBTQ children is a disturbing pattern among the Post Millennial's content.  Despite the fact that the man is acting in clear contravention of the court and attempting to impugn the case in doing so, The Post Millennial has promoted all content related to the man and his efforts, including online fundraisers to aid him in his efforts.  Upon the arrest of the man for contempt of court, The Post Millennial has characterised him as “the Canadian state’s prisoner of conscience,” and encouraged others to participate in similar “civil disobedience,” which would entail further harassment of transgender children. Writing for The Post Millennial, British transphobic activist Erin Perse directly refers to transitioning as an “undeniable social evil.” Because the bigoted harassment of children is acceptable to scum like Perse, but not that child’s choice to transition.  These disgusting talking points echo the homophobic arguments used to punish gay teens.  One of The Post Millennial’s more recent contributors is Michelle Cretella, the chair of the American College of Pediatricians, which is a misleadingly named anti-LGBTQ organisation that claims pedophilia and homosexuality are connected, and maintains ties to organisations dedicated to sexual conversion therapy for minors, which is a form of child abuse. Chad Felix Greene writes of homophobic and transphobic hate crimes as being caused by “deception” on the part of the victims.  In the articles of the Post Millennial, feminism and LGBT rights are reduced to a Western export, and the identities of transgender children are actively erased as slaves to “gender ideology.”  The Nazis once claimed that the existence of transgender people was a matter of political ideology too, decrying it as “Cultural Bolshevism” or “Sexual Bolshevism,” and used those claims to justify the arson of the Institut für Sexualwissenschaft.  These Nazi-era lies have been repackaged in The Post Millennial, much to the dishonour of owner Matthew Azreili’s Holocaust survivor ancestors.

   The Post Millennial is also engaged in denialism of political violence.  Leading up to the attack of 1/6, the Post Millennial explicitly promoted the social media platform Parler before every one of its articles.  This changed to a more general message: “If big tech continues censoring conservatives, that means our days on these platforms may be numbered. Please take a minute to sign up to our mailing list so we can stay in touch with you, our community. Subscribe Now!” In the months after the attack, The Post Millennial would engage in further denialism, equating peaceful demonstrations in state Capitols (Oklahoma, Iowa, and Georgia) to the mob of Trump supporters that killed a police officer and sought to murder lawmakers, chanting “Hang Mike Pence.”  In doing so the Post Millennial is attempting to normalise the attack, portraying it as “business as usual” among demonstrations.  None of these antiracism protests were violent, all involved went through security and protested either outside the chamber in the Capitol lobby or inside the gallery.  Other times, Post Millennial authors will go out of their way to justify and whitewash far-right extremist violence, usually by assassinating the character of the victims or blaming those same victims for the violence.  This was the case for Micah Fletcher, the survivor of a stabbing terrorist attack perpetrated by Patriot Prayer marcher Jeremy Christian. It was also the case for Garrett Foster, the man murdered in cold blood by a Trump supporter who accelerated his car into a crowd of people and fired his gun at them.  





Ngo uncritically presented the defence’s arguments as fact, and failed to follow up upon the expert testimony being discredited in court.  Ngo has a very consistent pattern of publishing apologia of far-right political violence and terrorism.

     Incitement and denialism are the tools of bigoted authoritarians. The Post Millennial builds a capacity to monetise political violence by using these tools, and through characteristics of its business model it shares with publications such as Der Sturmer, as described by Hubler.  Its editorial direction determines whom that violence is deployed towards, meaning people of colour, women, sexual minorities, and political opponents (usually alleged leftists). It seeks explicit depictions of its targets as a means of simultaneously indulging and validating its audience’s biases, and embarrassing its critics and opponents.  It is freely accessible to the broader public largely thanks to its wealthy owner and patron, Matthew Azreili, and seeks content from its extremist audience to minimise expenses and maintain its appeal to the far-right.  Its content may differ in its extreme messaging from the aforementioned historical forms of hate pornography, but it is hate pornography nonetheless. It would be remarkably easy to blame the Post Millennial’s editor-at-large for this behavior.  In truth however, Andy Ngo’s activities constitute only a segment of a broader pattern of malicious harassment by Post Millennial staff.  Ngo’s role in that pattern is significant, but the pattern itself predates his employment by The Post Millennial. Here are 5 current and former writers involved in malicious activities, or are strongly affiliated with those who are:




1. Nicholas Tomashheski, aka “Nick Monroe,” aka “PressFartToContinue”
   Nicholas Tomasheski is a former GamerGate activist, current Post Millennial contributor, and serial stalker known for targeting women in media.  Under his pseudonym “PressFartToContinue,” Tomasheski stalked video game streamer Brooke Thorne, aka PressHeartToContinue, aka Dodger, after the woman rebuffed his creepy advances and blocked him.  Tomasheski retaliated by posting Thorne’s personal information on the alt-right website 4chan.

  Later, Tomasheski as “PressFartToContinue” would go on to stalk video game journalist Brianna Wu, posting layouts of Wu’s house and address online as part of a harassment campaign that saw Wu sent numerous death threats.  In his Medium post containing information on Wu’s home, Tomasheski goes to great lengths to confirm information posted by @chatterwhiteman, a Twitter account linked to multiple death threats against Wu.  Considering the elevated profile of Tomasheski among GamerGaters, and the Post Millennial’s obsession with trying to revive the campaign, it is blatantly obvious that editorial staff are not only aware of Tomasheski’s past but hired him specifically for that past.



Tomasheski spread Wu’s personal information online, sourcing it from a Twitter handle that previously had sent Wu frequent death threats.  Tomasheski posted confirmations on Medium specifically to aid others in stalking Wu.

The entire premise of Gamergate was to harass women in media, principally journalists and women in the gaming industry.  Tomasheski was not just an active participant within Gamergate, he sought to enable others to join in escalating threats towards Brianna Wu.  Tomasheski is an example of how the most effective harassers among the Post Millennial’s extremist audience are recognised and given contributor status, effectively lending them a platform and outsourcing what is normally paid labour to its audience, much as Der Sturmer had done.  The Post Millennial has taken to promoting Tucker Carlson’s own harassment of New York Times journalist Taylor Lorenz, making it completely unsurprising for them to hire an alt-right troll and serial stalker like Tomasheski.  Tomasheski’s hiring has also proven to have emboldened the Post Millennial’s use of bigoted language to target critics of the Trump White House, going so far as to portray gay CNN journalist Don Lemon as “fellating” the legacy of President Barack Obama, and whine of Lemon’s refusal to equate anti-racist demonstrations with an attempt to violently overthrow the democratic government of the United States that saw multiple deaths.  The far-right media ecosystem The Post Millennial is situated in has increasingly legitimised incitement and violence towards the free press, behaviour that The Post Millennial itself is all too content to facilitate.





2. Anna Slatz, aka “YesThatAnna,” aka “Slatzism”

Anna Slatz is a disgraced editor of a New Brunswick university student paper, having been dumped by the paper after publishing uncritical interviews with a neo-Nazi leader that was seeking to recruit students on campus.  After Slatz’s firing, she was picked up by the Post Millennial, where she wrote articles about the tyranny of rainbow poppies, false information about hydroxychloroquine as a cure for Covid-19, and obsessive articles about transgender people.

During her time at Post Millennial, Slatz used the alt-right stalking forum KiwiFarms both for scoops and to promote her work.  Posting under YesThatAnna, Slatz used the website to smear GamerGate victim Zoe Quinn, the video game designer targeted by hordes of misogynistic trolls.  By her own admission, Slatz used a post from the website as the basis of an article on Post Millennial.  Slatz has also had her own meltdown on the forum, quitting the site only after having lost face with her audience. There is no way around the fact that the Post Millennial uses its platform in support of far-right harassment campaigns.  Moreover, it is indisputable that one of its staffers had an account on the website, and actively participated in the harassment on the forum.  Kiwi-Farms is not a normal forum, but a website dedicated to the harassment of women, sexual minorities, and the mentally disabled. It attracts a remarkably antisocial audience intent on malice.  Its owner and operator Joshua Conner Moon has previously been a moderator of the website 8Chan, but was removed for allegedly promoting pedophilia. Kiwifarms has been banned in New Zealand for hosting videos of the 2019 Christchurch mass shooting.  Upon requests by the police for compliance, Moon went off on an unhinged tirade.  Moon is unquestionably one of the most reprehensible human beings on the planet, posing the question of why a self-branded feminist would associate with his projects. 

  On June 29, 2016, an Ontario teenager was stalked and harassed until she committed suicide. Among the almost four thousand posts in a thread dedicated to her harassment, there were details of abuse from her boyfriend, mockery of her self-harm, links to her digital presence, and spreading her nude photos.  The Kiwifarms users stalking her would frequently send threats. They took a sick sense of pleasure out of stalking this girl, and celebrated upon learning of her suicide, knowing it was caused by their efforts.  They bragged about murdering her. Her name was Julia Terryberry.



Julia Terryberry was just one of many casualties of Kiwifarms users.  An entire thread dedicated to stalking the Ontario teenager was filled with sick bragging upon news of her death. 

     This Ontario teenager was murdered by the same mob The Post Millennial attempts to incite against its own perceived enemies.  For this reason alone, Slatz’s rebranding as a transphobic “feminist” should be recognised as being categorically disingenuous, as are the fundamentalist-astroturfed fringe “feminist” websites she publishes to.  In reality, Slatz has absolutely no qualms with hanging out on such a deeply hateful website, so long as its users are nice to her.  Slatz’s activities amounted to an attempt to cultivate an audience among the forum’s users, chiefly by demonstrating a willingness to amplify their messaging. Slatz has used the website multiple times as a source for material, effectively mainstreaming content from what is, and I cannot stress this enough, a neo-Nazi website dedicated to stalking women.  On one occasion, Slatz lifted an entire Kiwifarms post about Zoe Quinn, this time alleging that Quinn is culpable for the suicide of Alek Holowka.  Quinn, like Brianna Wu, has previously been subject to harassment as part of the alt-right campaign #GamerGate, which itself entailed the targeted harassment of almost exclusively female journalists, particularly those working in gaming media.  Holowka’s own sister took to twitter to slam Slatz’s slanderous articles as being disrespectful to Holowka’s memory. Slatz’s actions were a calculated attempt to incite misogynistic harassment against specific targets for her own monetary benefit.  Slatz was aware of the violence these women faced as a result of the Gamergate campaign, and she still chose to cultivate an audience of Gamergaters.



Slatz often showed her support to Kiwifarms users in their attempts to harass women, and sexual minorities.  Slatz’s conduct is a perfect example of how trans-exclusionary, so-called “radical feminists” are a front for a deeply misogynistic and homophobic movement.





Slatz's slander of Zoe Quinn received the ire of Holowka's sister, who has condemned Slatz and others for abusing Alec Holowka's memory for their own ends, including harassing the woman he abused.

     When identitarian pundits like Tucker Carlson put crosshairs on women like Taylor Lorenz, they fully understand that those they target will be subject to abuse from an extremist audience.  Knowing that Lorenz was already subject to harassment earlier in the year, Carlson would belittle the threats made against Lorenz’s safety.  Carlson doesn’t simply propagate the talking points of the Christchurch shooter’s manifesto, he deliberately creates an environment in which his radicalised audience may be incited to act violently.  Monetising incitement of mass violence is central to his show’s business model, just as it is the Post Millennial’s.  Kiwifarms already had a reputation for extremist violence when Slatz joined the forum.  It is completely inexplicable why a supposed feminist would join it, let alone use the site to outsource content creation.


Beth Baisch:

Much of Beth Baisch’s content of interest involves her on-the-ground sympathetic coverage afforded to anti-mask demonstrations in Toronto.  Baisch is accused of working alongside Ranendra Banerjee, a Hindutva (Hindu supremacist) extremist who in June of 2019 was part of a mob of religious fundamentalists that attacked anti-racist activists in Toronto’s Eaton Centre. Banerjee filmed himself planning the assault with Rick Boswick, telling their associates to prepare for a fight in the Eaton Centre.  Months later, the Post Millennial would publish information on one of the victims of that assault, spreading Boswick’s own harassment campaign of the victim to a national audience.  After helping incite death threats against the victim and his family, Anna Slatz would later badger the family for an interview, using the family’s fear to publicly shame the victim further.  On May 2021, Baisch published an article falsely claiming a member of the Jewish Defence League was beaten in an incident of antisemitic violence by demonstrators critical of Israeli war crimes in the Gaza Strip and West Bank.  In truth, the man in question was filmed swinging a baton and a knife at those same demonstrators.  JDL member Jordan Justein also attempted to hijack the demonstration by walking around with a megaphone and “antifa” sweater.  Justein was also involved in the gang assault in the Eaton Centre, fighting alongside members of the neo-Nazi organisation Canadian Nationalist Party.   Banerjee was also present at the event and flying an Indian flag alongside his JDL allies. 




The “elderly Jewish man” Baisch claimed was assaulted is pictured swinging a baton at a demonstrator from behind.  The presence of weapons, the footage showing Zazi Vili and other JDL members following, then confronting demonstrators, and the so-called Jewish Defence League’s prior history of conducting and supporting acts of terrorism all suggest the JDL premeditated another vicious gang assault.






JDL member Greg Nisan was portrayed as an elderly victim of antisemitic hate.  In reality, he and other JDL members approached a group of demonstrators while brandishing weapons. After losing his baton, Nisan took out a knife and tried attacking the demonstrators again.  The JDL has been involved in several assaults in the past, 
including an assault on former CJFE employee Kevin Metcalf, who has been targeted in the past by The Post Millennial.


     While Baisch’s heinous conduct and lack of ethics does not compare to the graveness of Slatz, Tomesheski, Ngo, or other hacks at the Post Millennial, her cooperation with violent hatemongers like Banerjee should be understood as part of a broader pattern in which Post Millennial staff propagate extremist messaging to cultivate a correspondingly extremist audience.  Banerjee’s own organisation, Hindu Canadian Advocacy (formerly Rise Canada), has been all too eager to show off on Twitter his contacts with both The Post Millennial (through Baisch) and with OpIndia, a propaganda arm of the regime of Narendra Modi.  OpIndia has faced accusations of inciting Islamophobic hatred, printing in 2019 a hateful piece of disinformation claiming a 15-year-old child was sacrificed in a mosque, a clear invocation of the antisemitic blood libel canard frequently used by Der Sturmer, this time repurposed to target Muslims.  OPIndia should be understood to be a mouthpiece of the BJP regime of Narendra Modi.   Similar to the Post Millennial, it is also widely condemned for its practice of targeting journalists it deems critical of the party serving as its patron, in this case being the BJP, and of the wider Hindu supremacist movement, just as the Post Millennial is criticized for targeting those critical of the Conservative Party of Canada and the Republican Party of the United States.  OpIndia’s founders are reportedly linked to both the BJP and the RSS, and have been sighted campaigning for the organisations. The organisation failed to accredit itself as a fact-checking organisation with the International Fact-Checking Network, owing completely to its role in producing disinformation, and hate and partisan propaganda. 

     Post Millennial’s cooperation with OpIndia is part of a broader pattern of reception to foreign influence operations.  This had previously manifested in the hiring of Cosmin Dzsurdzsa and Alexandra Hollenbeck as editors for the Canadian and American sections, respectively.  Both individuals have been reported as previously being involved in the production and publication of Russian disinformation on the Post Millennial.   Dzsurdzsa, working for Russia Insider, would have been on the payroll of Konstantin Malofeev, the oligarch sanctioned by Canada for his involvement in multiple influence operations across Ukraine, Africa, and the West. 













     Anti-mask propaganda, and more broadly disinformation surrounding the outbreak of Covid-19, has become the newest frontier for biowarfare among states.  Its proliferation by Russian information operations has been actively acknowledged by western security services.  The complementary narratives promoted in the Post Millennial’s content must be more closely scrutinised, given the site’s previous participation in Russian information operations during Alexandra Hollenbeck’s employment.  One of the key characteristics of authoritarians are their willingness to sell its services to whomever.  Authoritarians weaponise corruption to the ends of their clients and patrons, and subordinate foreign policy to the whims of those patrons. This fact was affirmed by Marie Yovanovitch in her Congressional testimony over the Ukrainian diplomatic crisis.  The Post Millennial should be recognised as propaganda for the authoritarian far-right that is not restrained to supporting a single movement, but instead promotes the broad interests of authoritarians everywhere.









 

Andy Ngo:



     Ngo is a far-right activist and the editor-at-large of the Post Millennial.  Ngo got his job at TPM just after the firing of Cosmin Dzsurdzsa and Alexandra Hollenbeck.  Although Ngo lacks the connections to Russian interests that his predecessors had, he has been equally dedicated to pushing an extremist agenda in his work, oftentimes working to protect violent far-right activists that he has connections to.  This was most evident when Ngo, then working for the alt-right blog Quillette, was present at Patriot Prayer’s assault on a Portland area bar and its patrons, during which a woman received spinal injuries.  Ngo not only initially failed to disclose his presence at the assault, but deliberately revealed the identity of the victim to his followers.   Ngo’s career in the past two years has revolved around publishing the names and photos of anti-racist protestors, often claiming involvement in rioting, even in instances where no one is charged. 



Ngo has a pattern of citing unrelated criminal histories in character assassinations of his targets.  One of the Patriot Prayer assailants charged for attacking Cider Riot is Matthew Demetrius Cooper, a convicted pedophile whose criminal history was not scrutinised by Ngo.  This failure to report on Cooper, given The Post Millennial’s habit of disproportionately publishing stories about sex crimes, and Ngo’s identification of Cooper’s victim both suggest that The Post Millennial is dedicated to producing hate propaganda specifically meant to target protected minorities and his opponents. As Showalter writes of Der Sturmer: “What is important is the fact that the correspondents believed that the seducers, cheats, vulgarians, and otherwise disreputable characters were Jewish.

After a Portland-area man was attacked at his house by far-right videographer Brandon Farley in the middle of the night, Ngo later identified the man to his twitter following, falsely portraying the man as the assailant, and inciting threats against the man and his family.  Ngo refused to provide additional context or make a correction.  Instead, Ngo opted to place the man’s personal information online as part of his Patreon content.  Farley has a history of stalking Portland residents he deems to be “antifa,” including harassing transgender photographer Nick Lee, against whom Farley has sent repeated rape threats and sexually harassing emails, which later degenerated into false sexual assault allegations towards Mr. Lee.  Farley has been a source for Post Millennial in the past, but has since apparently scrubbed credits to him in an apparent acknowledgement of guilt in enabling freaks like Farley.  However, Ngo has since taken to retweeting Farley’s videos.

   Like later hires, Ngo was hired by Post Millennial specifically for his role in an ecosystem of violent propaganda, a fact he is rather shameless about.  Ngo was fired from his first job at a student newspaper, the Vanguard, after falsely reporting on an interfaith panel at his university.  His editor, responding to criticisms from Ngo and far-right media, alleged Ngo’s intent for lying was to incite a reaction.  Later, Ngo would publish an anti-Muslim op-ed in the Wall Street Journal claiming that areas of London that banned public consumption of alcohol had done so due to supposed “Islamification” and multiculturalism.  Ngo has been unrepentant of this error, going so far as to name his Locals page the “Ngo-Go-Zone.”  This is a reference to the Islamophobic conspiracy theory of “no-go zones,” which allege that areas of western states are not welcome to those who do not behave in accordance to “Islamic customs,” for example by drinking alcohol or by women refusing to wear a burqa.  The fact that these supposed areas do not exist is of no consequence to Ngo, because his article is a shameless attempt to portray the existence of Muslims as a corrupting factor to liberal democratic values and an existential threat to democratic governance. 


     Ngo has frequently attempted to justify far-right extremist violence, usually assassinating the character of victims.  Following the indictments of three men for the lynching of Ahmaud Arbery, Ngo has claimed that Arbery would use jogging as an excuse to commit burglaries without evidence, instead simply and uncritically broadcasting the killers’ defence to his audience.  This has been a recurring pattern, as Ngo has in the past concerning the defence of white supremacist lone-wolf terrorist Jeremy Christian.  Ngo would air the statements of the defence’s “expert witness,” who claimed that the stabbing’s survivor, Micah Fletcher, was responsible for the murder.  The defence’s expert testimony was discredited for having not reviewed any materials relevant to the case.  Ngo’s attacks on victims would make Der Sturmer editor Julius Streicher proud, the latter having frequently engaged in slandering victims of antisemitic violence for over two decades.  It should be noted that slandering and dehumanising lynching victims was a common practice among media sympathetic to the perpetrators.







Ngo’s work also frequently sexualises its subjects.  Ngo brings up his targets’ histories in the sex industry, both as a means of humiliation and as a means of titillating his viewers with smut and fantasies.  It is also a means of inciting violence towards vulnerable peoples, of which sex workers are obviously included.  When doxxing sex worker Renea Goddard, Ngo made sure to let his followers know that Goddard was older than she portrays herself, intentionally exposing her to backlash and stalking from her clients.  A gay man is identified alongside a photo of him in BDSM gear and accusations of rioting.  Lynching victim George Floyd is reduced to being a “former porn star.” One target chosen for a smear has her tweets indicating an interest in taking up sex work archived for Ngo’s audience. The subject becomes an object of both revulsion and sexualization that satisfies the carnal desires of Ngo’s audience and validates their preconceived stereotypes.    







Ngo has repeatedly disrespected another lynching victim, George Floyd.  Ngo reduces Floyd to being a “late porn star” as a means of trying to tarnish Floyd’s legacy and embarrass Floyd’s family. 



In his book, Ngo falsely attributes Floyd’s death to intoxicants.  Autopsy records shown in the trial of Derek Chauvin reveal that traumatic asphyxia was the cause of Floyd’s death. Ngo is also citing pathologist Andrew Baker, who explicitly stated in those same notes that he was not saying that Floyd died of an overdose. 








Just like Kiwifarms, Tomasheski, and Der Sturmer, Ngo goes out of his way to subject women to misogynistic harassment.  Ngo targeted the sex worker Renea Goddard by publishing personal information on the woman, including that Goddard portrayed herself as being younger in order to maximise her earnings.  This information was completely irrelevant to Ngo’s stated purpose, and its publication was intended solely to incite harassment towards Goddard.

In February of 2021, Ngo appeared on the Ingraham Angle, a Fox News show hosted by Laura Ingraham, to discuss Ngo’s congressional testimony during hearings on domestic terrorism and the January 6 attack on the United States Capitol.  Ngo was a partisan invitee for the Republican Party, whose members have been accused of inciting and in some cases participating in the attack.  Ngo’s testimony was completely focused on so-called “antifa terrorism,” a term which has no recognition among credible CTE officials, including Ngo’s co-panelists.  Ngo has no experience in counterterrorism but is more than willing to slander those who do.  On the Ingraham Angle, Ngo took to baselessly claiming that his congressional co-panelist Malcolm Nance attempted to incite via Twitter an ISIS attack against Trump Tower Istanbul.  In reality, Nance was publicly making an assessment of likely targets by ISIS, an organisation that Nance was involved in combating.  Nance’s own book, Hacking ISIS was recommended by Donald Trump.  Nance faced death threats immediately following Ngo’s appearance on the Ingraham Angle.  This disingenuous lie had already been debunked prior, but Ngo chose to revive it as a means of slandering one of the several co-panelists that rebuked Ngo’s claims.   Ngo is more than willing to slander war heroes for his own benefit, regardless of the danger his targets face.  It should be noted that at least two Republican congressmen focused on questioning Ngo regarding so-called “antifa violence” were either involved in planning the riot (Representative Andy Biggs), praised the rioters (Gohmert), or have spread disinformation over the attack incited by Donald Trump.  Ngo’s central role in the Republican Party’s farce is further demonstrative of his sympathies to far-right extremis willingness to downplay the threat posed by far-right extremism, including comparisons to so-called “antifa violence” that were promptly rebuked by multiple co-panelists. Ngo has also asserted that various journalists are "antifa sympathisers," leading to threats against them.  These include against Brandy Zadrony, Robert Evans, and Dr. Alexander Reid Ross
 

  
Ngo’s slander of Nance was part of a concerted effort by far-right pundits to discredit the counterterrorism professionals that gave testimony on February 24, 2021.  At 43:30, Nance reads a death threat sent to him following Ngo’s slander.  By cultivating an extremist audience and generating material meant to further radicalise readers, Ngo has helped engineer a means of commercialising political violence.  Ngo’s targets have been consistently threatened with injury and death, owing completely to the often misleading (if not outright slanderous) claims made in Ngo’s propaganda.

 

    In October of 2019, Ngo doxed the Toronto-area antifascist Alaa Soufi, acting on a lead from a fake “intelligence contractor” calling itself EXEINTEL.  While this in itself would normally be considered an embarrassment to a respectable publication, “EXEINTEL” pulled its information from a Kiwifarms thread that itself lifted its information on Soufi and their family by the alt-right agitator Rick Boswick.   Boswick was previously involved in attacks on Pride parades by a roving group of violent homophobes and the neo-Nazi Canadian Nationalist Party.  The attack in Hamilton preceded an even more violent attack in Toronto which saw one Pride Defender hospitalised.  Boswick and Ranendra (Ron) Banerjee filmed themselves discussing their intent to both attack Pride and antiracist activists. After the assault, Boswick published multiple videos initiating doxing campaigns against the victims, including Soufi, Sarah Hegazi, and Toronto-area journalist Kevin Metcalf.  Ngo published sensationalised stories of a Hamilton antiracist demonstration portraying both Alaa Soufi and Kevin Metcalf as violent aggressors after demonstrators were attacked by members of the terrorist organisation Proud Boys.  Not only did Ngo elevate Boswick’s harassment campaign against the victims of Boswick and his associates, Ngo constructed additional disinformation to incite his audience towards the Soufi family and other victims of Boswick’s harassment.  The restaurant owned and run by the Soufi family had to briefly shut down, owing to the threats Ngo helped incite. The Post Millennial has also falsely accused Metcalf of being an aggressor after Metcalf was assaulted by far-right demonstrators, including a member of the Jewish Defence League (JDL).  Boswick was (and still is) facing charges of uttering threats towards Mr. Metcalf prior to both attacks, making The Post Millennial’s targeting and false portrayal of Metcalf especially egregious.  Ngo and the Post Millennial elevated Boswick’s campaign from the fringes of Canadian hate movements to the forefront of far-right press around the world. 





  A Twitter account run by the “CEO” of EXEINTEL posted false information that Sarah Hegazi was present in Hamilton, using Ngo’s story to leverage harassment to alternative targets.  This is also further evidence of the (false) information being lifted from Kiwifarms. Sarah Hegazi committed suicide a year to the date of the attack on Toronto Pride.  Ngo and The Post Millennial’s sensationalised reports legitimised sources known to spread disinformation about anti-racist activists, with absolutely no concern for the truth.  Hegazi was also subject to a doxing video by Rick Boswick that was meant to intimidate her and other victims of his associates into silence. Hegazi was a lesbian activist who had previously been imprisoned and tortured by the Sisi dictatorship in Egypt.  Hegazi was one of many brave individuals who worked to protect Toronto Pride from attacks by Boswick and his associates.  The vicious gang assault of June 23 in the Eaton Centre was a premeditated hate crime that was never prosecuted.  At least three of its victims have been the target of disinformation that largely borrows from malicious actors, including from a participant of the aforementioned hate crime (being Boswick).  The Post Millennial acted as the means of legitimising this campaign in the mainstream, and their participation in Boswick’s campaign will not be forgotten.  


Kiwifarms user Bryan Trottier was the source for Post Millennial’s slander of Kurt Phillips.  He takes credit for the suicide of Sarah Hegazi, who was targeted by Ngo’s other sources on Kiwifarms.

    In February of last year, Boswick associate Bryan Trottier posted the personal information of anti-racist activist Kurt Phillips on Kiwifarms.  Phillips has reported on neo-Nazi terrorist and otherwise violent extremist groups in Canada for over a decade.  Trottier has also stalked Kevin Metcalf persistently, a fact that Metcalf has documented on his Twitter.  In one of his most heinous messages to Metcalf, Trottier relishes in the possibility that he might be responsible for Hegazi’s suicide.  Ngo used Trottier’s dox as the basis of false allegations against Phillips, which he retweeted to his audience.  Phillips has since come public about the threats he received, many of which cited Ngo’s slanderous tweets about him.


Ngo’s expansive extremist following regularly threatens those he slanders.  His history of collaboration with extremist organisations such as Patriot Prayer has given Ngo a reputation among other extremists as a valuable mouthpiece.  Ngo has previously been criticized during his Quillette stint for publishing an article from far-right troll and fraudster Eoin Lenihan listing critics as “propagandists for antifa.” That article served the basis of a kill-list of the neo-Nazi terrorist organisation Atomwaffen.

  Although Ngo has not (to my knowledge) followed the clumsy example of Anna Slatz and directly solicited Kiwifarms users on their forum to provide content, Ngo is more than willing to amplify their campaigns for his own financial benefit.  That said, Ngo was not the only Post Millennial contributor to slander Phillips.  There is a much more interesting character that did the same thing, but not on the Post Millennial…

 

 

Brad Betters, aka Bradley Betters, aka Bradford HB, aka Paul Bradford:

Writing for Human Events, Brad Betters introduced Phillips to an American audience, using Rebel Media and Andy Ngo’s tweet to validate his article.  Betters has previously written for The Post Millennial (here, here, here, here), prior to Ngo joining the company.  Betters is seemingly dedicated to white supremacist propaganda, including positive coverage of fringe far-right politician Maxime Bernier, complaints of children of immigrants being born as Canadian citizens, and paranoia of white people being made minorities, the basis of the “Great Replacement” in neo-Nazi propaganda.  On other sites, the “Brad Army” has written complaints of “anti-white animus,” “woke excesses,” claims that the Canadian Anti-Hate Network is “funding Canadian antifa,” and attacks on individuals critical of the government of the Russian Federation such as Fiona Hill.


I have been observing these authors for some time, and have reached the following conclusions:

Brad Betters does not exist
Brad Betters uses a photo of a Belarusian labour activist named Anatoly Myshkevich and has passed it off as himself.
Other personas utilise an edited photo of Myshkevich, most notably “Bradford H.B.”


The utilisation of fake personas isn’t unique to the Post Millennial. Der Sturmer’s audience frequently used initials or false names to prevent themselves from being identified, usually when slandering others.  What is unique to the Post Millennial is that there is a distinct possibility that these personas may be part of a foreign influence operation.  One such operation designed to promote the interests of the United Arab Emirates was uncovered by the Daily Beast.  However, the “Brad Army” predates articles from personas outed by the Daily Beast.  After being contacted by The Daily Beast for comment, The Post Millennial removed identified false personas and their articles without explanation, fitting the aforementioned pattern of self-censorship to avoid scrutiny and accountability.



Another persona named Paul Bradford describes himself with similar vagueness, calling himself a “Capitol Hill refugee now earning an honest living.”  Thematic analysis of the writings produced by “Paul Bradford” reveals a preoccupation with the same themes as “Brad Betters” and “Bradford H.B.”  Attacks towards a vaguely defined “radical left,” and towards figures involved in investigations of Russian interference in the 2016 and 2020 United States presidential elections.   The overarching thematic pattern however is the constant validation of white nationalist and authoritarian propaganda.  Paul Bradford will claim the left is more “concerned about law-abiding gun owners than rioters,” then defend the Capitol insurrectionists, including the “zip-tie guy,” whose use of the restraints were indicative of a plan to take hostages.  That man, Eric Munschel, carried weapons with him into Washington D.C. on that day.  Authorities later uncovered a stockpile of weapons, including a sniper rifle and tripod, at the man’s apartment. The fake persona’s denialism of 1/6 betrays the secrecy of its goal to radicalise Americans to perpetuate future political violence.   “Paul Bradford” is likely an amalgamation of far-right American political activists Paul Gottfried and Mel Bradford, whom have both been cited by “Bradford H.B.”  Paul Bradford’s Muckrack page notably includes links from unrelated people. 

What I found most interesting is that there are commonly referenced pundits between the opinion pieces of each persona: Andy Ngo.  Similarly, Ngo has referenced articles from the personas.  In Ngo’s book, he refers to the National Lawyer’s Guild as the “legal arm” of the antifascist movement, borrowing language directly from an American Greatness article written by Betters, which Ngo has promoted. 


 

To clarify: I did not purchase Andy Ngo’s shitty book.

There is significant overlap of platforms willing to publish these fake personas.  Many of the same outlets that published fake personas identified by the Daily Beast have also published articles from the Brad Army.  These include:  The Post Millennial, C2C Journal, South China Morning Herald, Aero, Spiked, American Greatness, American Thinker, Chronicles Magazine, Taki Mag, The Federalist, CNSNews, Quillette, and Human Events.  A running theme among these publications (barring SCMP) is the consistent far-right and often racist editorial position.  Another is that several publications are reliant on funding from think tanks and activist millionaires, and may suggest these platforms were knowledgeable of the nature of these personas.  These think tanks include: The Manning Foundation, The Rockford Institute, Media Research Center, Center for American Greatness, and American Spectator Foundation. The notable shift from publishing in white nationalist magazine Taki Mag to publishing in mainstream conservative outlets about supposed “abuse” of fascism as a label (but simultaneously claiming antifascists are themselves fascists) demonstrates a clear example of how far-right extremism is being mainstreamed in American media, a finding I have no doubt the targets of the Post Millennial would concur with.

 



Brad Army Archive:

Bradford Betters:

BradleyBetters, Author at Taki's Magazine - Taki's Magazine (takimag.com)

C2C Journal:

Why Do the Liberals Love Hate Speech Laws? | C2C Journal (archive.org)

Immigration and the National Interest | C2C Journal (archive.org)

 


Bradley Betters:

The Populists Next Door No One's Talking About - American Thinker (archive.org) (changed to Bradford HB)

Antifa’s Most Important Enabler: Its Legal Arm - American Greatness (archive.org)

US-China trade war – why everything you thought you knew is wrong | South China Morning Post (archive.org) (changed to Bradford H.B.)

The SPLC: how hate-monitoring became big business - spiked (archive.org)

Justin Trudeau's Postnationalism (archive.org)

Amnesty: Bad Policy, Even Worse Politics (archive.org)

SPLC, ADL, and the 'White Nationalism' Panic (archive.org)


Brad Betters:


The Right Versus the Axis of Wokeness | Chronicles (archive.org)

Conservatives could be winning big votes on this issue in Burnaby South: birth tourism | The Post Millennial (archive.org)

Bernier’s immigration policy is backed by his libertarian ideals | The Post Millennial (archive.org)

BETTERS: Why didn’t the candidates raise the issue of housing demand in Burnaby South? | The Post Millennial (archive.org)

Conservatives must listen to their base on immigration, not the left-wing media | The Post Millennial (archive.org)

Reports About 'Hate Groups' Aim To Panic Us Into Speech Controls (archive.org)

Illegal Immigration and the Trade War (archive.org)

'Anti-Hate' Southern Poverty Law Center Partner Funds Violent Antifa (archive.org)

To Aid Vulnerable Workers Post-COVID, We Must Fix Our Immigration Law (archive.org)

Antifa's Open Borders Push Proves They're Anti-American, Not Antifascist (archive.org)

Biden Transition Pick Cecilia Munoz's Dark Ties to Soros and 'Eliminate the Gringo' La Raza Founder | CNSNews (archive.org)

If California’s Affirmative Action Ban Gets Trashed, Blame Never-Trumpers | CNSNews (archive.org)

Five Reasons Democrats Truly Are the Real Racists | CNSNews (archive.org)

You’re Not Antiracist If You Hide Crimes Due To The Perpetrators’ Race (archive.org)






Bradford H.B.

When Doxers Become the Doxed. | Human Events (archive.org)

Dumbing Fascism Down, Then And Now – Quillette (archive.org)

The Abuse of "Fascism." | Human Events (archive.org)

The Great White Awokening: How Conservatives Can Temper Woke Excesses and Assuage White Guilt - Areo (archive.org)

Conservative Cancel Culture: Paul E. Gottfried et al's "The Vanishing Tradition: Perspectives on American Conservatism" - Areo (archive.org)

Found: White America’s Lost Moral Authority. | Human Events (archive.org)

What Needs ‘Repairing’ Isn’t America, But White Guilt (archive.org)

No Mercy for Miller, But Plenty for the Dems | The American Spectator | USA News and Politics (archive.org)

The Abusive Relationship Between White Guilt and Black Power | The American Spectator | USA News and Politics (archive.org)

The Neocon Roots of Our Current Crisis - American Greatness (archive.org)

The Amorality of the Left’s Equality Extremism (archive.org)

The Other 1619 Project - American Greatness (archive.org)





Slatz Archive:

Profile:  https://web.archive.org/web/20210402083859/https://kiwifarms.net/members/yesthatanna.42263/

Slatz 8-21-2019  http://web.archive.org/web/20210402084104/https://kiwifarms.net/threads/8-21-19-suspected-ryan-gordon-yanivs-agent-pays-a-visit-to-the-farms.59996/page-43

Slatz 8-21-2019  http://web.archive.org/web/20210402084251/https://kiwifarms.net/threads/8-21-19-suspected-ryan-gordon-yanivs-agent-pays-a-visit-to-the-farms.59996/page-44

Slatz  8-21-2019 http://web.archive.org/web/20210402084450/https://kiwifarms.net/threads/8-21-19-suspected-ryan-gordon-yanivs-agent-pays-a-visit-to-the-farms.59996/page-45
End of page 7
---------------------------------
Slatz  Using KiwiFarms as a source https://kiwifarms.net/threads/zoe-quinn-chelsea-van-valkenburg-locke-valentine-unburntwitch-primeape-crashoverride-hat-box-old-uncle-anime.14263/page-866#post-5309136

Slatz Using Kiwifarms as a source https://web.archive.org/web/20210402090826/https://kiwifarms.net/threads/zoe-quinn-chelsea-van-valkenburg-locke-valentine-unburntwitch-primeape-crashoverride-hat-box-old-uncle-anime.14263/page-862












Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A response to Drew's criticism